View all insights
image

Comparison of value creation, North America vs Asia

So far we’ve examined revenue growth and EBITDA margins in Asia and North America as part of our private equity data analysis on the underlying operating performance of portfolio companies in these two important markets. The third driver of enterprise value development in private equity value creation is multiple expansion. (Just to clarify, there is a common misconception that leverage is part of value creation when in fact leverage impacts equity and not enterprise value.)

As shown in the figure below of the value creation bridge on EBITDA development for Asia deals between 2004 and 2018, the single largest driver is Revenue Growth with a 60% contribution of the total value creation of enterprise value, which aligns with our previous analysis on revenue CAGR that showed the outperformance of revenue growth for Asia portfolio companies. The third step in this value creation step-chart is EBITDA Margin Expansion which is actually a low contributor to value creation at just 3% when we aggregate all Asia deals across the 15 year period.

Another important driver is Multiple Expansion on Exit EBITDA, the fourth step in the chart, which captures the value creation based on EBITDA development that is due to the aggregated effects of revenue growth and changes on the EBITDA multiple over the lifetime of the deal; it has the following calculation:

Enterprise Value Creation due to Multiple Expansion on Exit EBITDA = (Exit EBITDA Multiple - Entry EBITDA Multiple) * Exit EBITDA

As shown in this simple formula, there are three variables that contribute to this calculation and both Exit EBITDA Multiple and Exit EBITDA can fluctuate in either positive or negative directions during the course of the GP’s investment holding period. This means that the overall effect can be due to a combination of changes - pricing multiple and EBITDA. While we can’t clearly distinguish between multiple arbitrage (GPs buying low and selling high) and actual operational improvements that drive up the Exit EBITDA, what we want to see is an overall positive contribution. For Asia deals, Multiple Expansion on Exit EBITDA is the second largest contributor at 37% of the overall enterprise value created.

Value Creation based on EBITDA development in USD - 1969 deals are included in this analysis

The value creation bridge for North America deals between 2004 and 2018 is somewhat similar with the two largest drivers being Revenue Growth and Multiple Expansion on Exit EBITDA at 36% and 57%, respectively, as shown in the figure below. However, more important is that Margin Expansion is also very low at just 7% which is just slightly better than the 3% for Asia.

From these value creation analysis charts, it is interesting (and ironic) to see that improving EBITDA margins at portfolio companies play such a small role to drive positive enterprise value development in both Asia and North America. For now, returns are based on value creation that is driven by growing revenue and multiple expansion, which works well in a positive market environment, but what happens in a weak market? Further analysis on this topic would be to dissect the timeframe into pre- and post-financial crisis eras to evaluate the value creation drivers.

Value Creation on EBITDA development in USD - 12634 deals included in this analysis

Want to try out an analysis yourself? Register today – it’s free!

Portfolio insights
Portfolio management
Market research

Read next

image

Infrastructure Investment Strategies

Infrastructure is the backbone of a country that provides the most basic of necessities such as water, energy and waste management, followed by other additional services such as transportation and communication.

image

Private Markets Deal-level DPI Returns Softening in Response to Weak Market

The latest CEPRES Private Capital Market Outlook shows how Q2 2020 M&A deal value in the US declined by 60% quarter-on-quarter which also represents a 50% decrease year-on-year.

image

CEPRES highlights best sectors for post-Coronavirus market

The latest analysis from CEPRES highlights major sectors that could be positively and negatively impacted by the Coronavirus crisis.

Client Exclusives

Private credit: Spotlight on deals — the winners and losers & bounce back from the crisis

Read more
image

Navigating Private Debt: A Deep Dive into Historical Risk and Returns

Read more
image